National Cybersecurity
Association of Ukraine

How reputational pressure works through networks of sites.

Analytical note ·

A publication, then contact, then an offer to take it down for money. This note describes the usual sequence, why deletion rarely ends it, and what an organisation facing it should do.

In short

  • The method rests on volume rather than on one article: the same text appears on dozens of domains, in several languages, under changed headlines.
  • Volume creates the impression of independent confirmation where there is a single source.
  • Removing one address usually does not end the story; it supplies the subject of the next article.
  • In the first days, the most useful thing an organisation can do is record, not react.

The usual sequence

First comes the initial publication, written to index well: the name of the person or company in the headline, in the page address and in the opening sentences.

The same text then spreads to other domains, in whole or in part, across languages. Headlines change; the substance does not.

Then contact is made. It may come through an intermediary, through someone presenting themselves as a representative of the site, or through someone offering help with removal.

After a refusal, or after attempts to have the material taken down by other means, the number of publications typically grows and the subjects widen.

Ukrainian media have reported cases in which specific sums were named for removal, starting from a few thousand dollars. Those reports concern particular incidents and do not describe the whole set of sites that may republish content.

Why deletion rarely helps

A search engine displays a page; it does not hold it. If the text remains on even one domain in the network, removing the rest changes the number of results rather than the availability of the claim.

Services that generate answers over search read what is reachable at the moment of the query. A removed page leaves their answers only once it has left every mirror and the cache.

The removal itself often becomes the subject of a new article. It is a convenient story: it requires no new facts and is presented as proof that there is something to hide.

For that reason the sequence of find, ask for removal, remove often ends with more publications than it started with.

What an organisation should do

  • Record. Save pages to archiving services, take screenshots showing the address and the date, and keep a register: address, domain, date of appearance, language, whether mirrors exist.
  • Do not negotiate payment. Paying confirms that the method works and rarely ends the matter.
  • Keep every contact. Correspondence and messages carrying demands are evidence, not a nuisance.
  • Approach law enforcement and regulators rather than the sites themselves.
  • In parallel, build your own sources: pages carrying facts, documents and dates on domains you control. That is the only part fully within your control.

The limits of this note

The note describes a general mechanic reported by Ukrainian media and by open-source researchers. It does not establish that particular domains are connected, it names no individuals, and it draws no conclusion about the lawfulness of any act.

Technical indications of a connection between individual domains are examined in the separate note on the monitoring of 45 web domains.

The 45-domain monitoring note